Originally Posted by HeilSvenska
Maybe for you...
I have seen all those cars in person. Have you?
|
Yes, and I've driven the '05+ Mustang and the new Challenger.
The Mustang is a cluster fuck. J Mays' attempt at retro failed. Everything past the doors is hopeless. The car looks heavy and the high belt line / low greehouse gives it a mobile bunker look. I'll keep my 2004 Mach 1.
The Challenger is better, but suffers from the high cowl necessary because of the use of the 300C / Charger platform. Compare it to the more svelte lines of the original.
The new Camaro is pretty good, but suffers froma little too much retro-itis. The problem here (and for the Mustang and Challenger)is that cars of the '60s and '70s were not burdened with crash regulations, bumper standards, etc. Compare a '71 Challenger to the new one and a '68 Mustang to the '05. The new cars look ponderous, the originals reletively lithe.
The Genesis is a clean very attractive design unburdened by trying to evoke 40 year old memories. If it had any other company's name, you'd like it much better.